Fiber Library

What is Cotton

Cotton is the soft fiber that grows around the seeds of the cotton plant. When the seed pod, called a boll, ripens and splits open, the fluffy white fiber inside is picked and run through a gin, a machine that pulls the fiber away from the seeds. The fiber is cleaned, combed so the strands lie side by side, and twisted into yarn, which is then knitted or woven into fabric. Nothing is dissolved along the way, so the fiber in a cotton t-shirt is the same fiber that came off the plant.

How it's made
  1. 1Cotton bollThe fiber grows around the seeds and is picked when the pod splits
  2. 2GinnedA machine pulls the fiber away from the seeds
  3. 3SpunCleaned, combed, and twisted into yarn. Nothing is dissolved
The label says
COTTONORGANIC COTTON

US rules require each fiber and its percentage. “Organic” is a separate claim about how the crop was grown.

Watch for
  • Blends
    95% COTTON5% SPANDEX
    Fail

    Spandex and polyester are synthetics. Our standard excludes them at any percentage, so a blend fails.

  • Organic claims
    ORGANIC COTTON
    Natural only

    No license number, so the claim is unconfirmed. It passes Natural only.

    ORGANIC COTTONGOTS ORGANICLICENSE NO. 000000
    Pure

    Certified to GOTS at its top grade, with a license number we can look up. It passes Pure.

  • Chemical finishes
    STAIN-RESISTANT
    Fail

    Stain- and water-repellent finishes are often made with PFAS, the “forever chemicals.” A product that makes this claim doesn’t pass.

At Jacob Gray Goods

All cotton passes. Only GOTS‑certified organic cotton reaches Pure.

Natural
Pass
Conventional or organic
Pure
With GOTS
Only with GOTS “organic” grade

The length of each fiber, called its staple, shapes how the fabric feels. Longer fibers spin into a smoother, stronger yarn, and that length is what names like Pima and Egyptian are really about. Pima is a type of extra-long-staple cotton grown in several countries. Supima is a trademark licensed only for products made from 100% American-grown Pima. Egyptian cotton is cotton grown in Egypt. All three names describe fiber length or origin, and none of them says how the cotton was farmed or finished.

So cotton is a plant fiber from start to finish, and the differences between one cotton shirt and another come from how it was grown and what it was treated with afterward.

Source for this section: Farm Progress, Supima puts supreme Pima on the map.

What the label says

United States textile rules require the label to name each fiber and its percentage, and for cotton the name is simply cotton. "Organic cotton" is a separate claim about how the crop was grown. Two certifications stand behind it on clothing, GOTS (Global Organic Textile Standard) and OCS (Organic Content Standard), and a real certification comes with a license number you can look up on the certifier's public database.

Sources for this section: 16 CFR Part 303; USDA National Organic Program, Policy Memo 11-14, Labeling of Textiles; GOTS, Global Organic Textile Standard Version 7.0, March 2023, section 2.7.

Where you'll run into it

Baby clothing is built around cotton: bodysuits, footed pajamas, rompers, sleep sacks, socks, and hats. For adults it's t-shirts, jeans, underwear, button-down shirts, sweatshirts, and socks.

Does organic matter to the wearer?

Organic certification is about the farm. Organic cotton is grown without synthetic pesticides or fertilizers, and conventional cotton uses both. Its outsized share is in insecticides: the International Cotton Advisory Committee puts cotton at about 4% of the world's pesticide use and about 10.5% of its insecticides, grown on about 2.3% of its farmland, over 2018 to 2022.

We found very little published testing of finished clothing for farm pesticides. One small 2011 study followed a sprayed insecticide through conventional cotton: it turned up on the raw fiber, but testing couldn't find it in the yarn or fabric made from that fiber. That is a single small study, so it doesn't settle the question.

The dyes, softeners, and resins added after the yarn is spun, however, are what stays on the fabric. This is where the two certifications differ. GOTS covers processing as well as farming, and it bans formaldehyde, toxic heavy metals, PFAS (the "forever chemicals"), and dyes that release cancer-causing compounds. OCS tracks organic content through the supply chain and does not set rules for the chemicals used along the way.

So organic matters most to the farm and the people who work it. For the wearer, the finishing is the part that touches skin, and GOTS is the certification that covers it.

Sources for this section: International Cotton Advisory Committee, Cotton Recorder 2, 2024; Acharya N.G. Ranga Agricultural University, Impact of pesticide residues on physico-chemical properties of organic and non-organic cotton, 2011; GOTS, Version 7.0, section 4.2; ICEA, Organic Content Standard.

What to watch for

A bodysuit, leggings, or footed pajamas sold as cotton can turn out to be 95% cotton and 5% spandex. Spandex is a synthetic, so that garment doesn't pass our standard.

"Organic cotton" on a hangtag or product page is only a claim until a certification stands behind it. GOTS requires its label to show the grade and the license number of the certified company, so a GOTS logo with no number is incomplete, and you can look up a number in GOTS's public database. If no certification is named, or the number doesn't turn up, there's no way to confirm the cotton is organic.

Poly-cotton blends are sold as durable and easy to care for, and the polyester is why they shrink less and dry faster.

A fabric name is not a fiber name. French terry, jersey, interlock, fleece, flannel, and muslin all describe how a fabric is knitted or woven. For example, French terry, the knit with soft loops on the back used for rompers, joggers, and sweatshirts, can be all cotton, cotton and polyester, or cotton with spandex.

"Stain-resistant" and "water-repellent" point to a chemical finish, and it is often made with PFAS, the "forever chemicals." A 2022 study of 72 children's products marketed as stain-resistant, mostly school uniforms, found PFAS in every one, and the uniforms made of 100% cotton carried more than the cotton-synthetic blends.

Better Cotton is a farming program that works to reduce pesticide use. It isn't organic, and the label doesn't mean the cotton in that garment came from a Better Cotton farm, so a brand can lean on the name to sound greener than the garment is. Our field guide to greenwashing covers how claims like this work.

Recycled cotton comes out shorter after shredding, so it can be spun with another fiber for strength, and that fiber can be polyester. Read the rest of the label.

Sources for this section: GOTS, Global Organic Textile Standard Version 7.0, sections 2.7.4 and 2.7.8; Xia et al., Per- and Polyfluoroalkyl Substances in North American School Uniforms, Environmental Science & Technology 56(19), 2022; Better Cotton, 2030 pesticide reduction target (via Just Style).

Cotton at Jacob Gray Goods

Cotton is a plant fiber, so it clears our baseline and passes in the Natural tier, whether it's conventional or organic. It reaches Pure only when it's certified to GOTS at its top grade, labeled "organic," and the license number checks out on GOTS's public database. Cotton with any other organic certification, or an organic claim we can't look up, stays Natural.

Get the newsletter

Subscribe for access to our newsletter, exciting updates, and more.

Keep reading